Skip to main content

Blue Guardian vs NYS Markets comparison

As of · prices, rules and payout terms

Based on CFD plans

Futures, Crypto plans are on each firm's page.

PropFirmTier Research ·

At a glance

  • Lowest price per $10KBlue Guardian: $0.50 · NYS Markets: $9.90
  • Max profit splitBlue Guardian: 90% · NYS Markets: 80%
  • Payout timeBlue Guardian: Same day to 1 day · NYS Markets: 1–2 days

Based only on published rules and prices. Which one suits you depends on how you trade.

Verdict at a glance

Reasons to pick Blue Guardian

  • Lowest price per $10K: $0.50 (vs NYS Markets $9.90)
  • Profit split (highest): 90% · Up to 100% with add-ons (vs NYS Markets 80% · Up to 100% with add-ons)
  • Payout time: Same day to 1 day (vs NYS Markets 1–2 days)
  • Profit target (lowest): 4% (vs NYS Markets 6%)
  • Fee refund: Refunded on some plans (vs NYS Markets No refund)

Each list shows only the published figures where that firm comes out ahead. Which one suits you depends on how you trade and the account size you want.

Side-by-side comparison

Price

Lowest fee
Blue Guardian: from $26.66First payment incl. activation fee$5K account plan
NYS Markets: from $38$10K account plan
Lowest price per $10K
Blue Guardian: $0.50 (better)
NYS Markets: $9.90
Account sizes
Blue Guardian: $5K–$400K
NYS Markets: $5K–$200K
Max allocation
Blue Guardian: $750,000
NYS Markets: No info
Fee refund
Blue Guardian: Varies by planRefunded with payout #4 · No refund
NYS Markets: No refund

Targets & loss limits

Profit target (lowest)
Blue Guardian: 4% (better)
NYS Markets: 6%
Daily loss limit (highest)
Blue Guardian: 4%
NYS Markets: 5%Some plans have no limit (better)
Max drawdown (highest)
Blue Guardian: 10%
NYS Markets: 10%
Drawdown type
Blue Guardian: Other, ​Static
NYS Markets: Intraday trailing, ​Static, ​EOD trailing
Minimum trading days (fewest)
Blue Guardian: None (better)
NYS Markets: 1 day
Time limit
Blue Guardian: Unlimited
NYS Markets: Unlimited
Consistency rule
Blue Guardian: Varies by plan
NYS Markets: Yes (varies by plan)

Payouts

Profit split (highest)
Blue Guardian: 90%Up to 100% with add-ons (better)
NYS Markets: 80%Up to 100% with add-ons
First payout (soonest)
Blue Guardian: 14 days
NYS Markets: No info
Payout frequency (shortest)
Blue Guardian: Anytime
NYS Markets: No info
Payout eligibility (lowest)
Blue Guardian: 0 profitable daysMin. request $100
NYS Markets: 5 profitable daysMin. request $50
First payout cap
Blue Guardian: $250–$10,000
NYS Markets: $100–$4,000
Payout time
Blue Guardian: Same day to 1 day (better)
NYS Markets: 1–2 days
Payout methods
Blue Guardian: Crypto, ​Rise
NYS Markets: Crypto

Rules

Daily reset time
Blue Guardian: UTC 22:00 · US Eastern 17:00
NYS Markets: UTC 21:00
Scalping
Blue Guardian: Restricted
NYS Markets: No info
News trading
Blue Guardian: Varies by plan
NYS Markets: Varies by plan
EAs
Blue Guardian: Allowed
NYS Markets: No info
Weekend holding
Blue Guardian: Allowed
NYS Markets: No info
Platforms
Blue Guardian: MT5, ​Match-Trader, ​TradeLocker, ​Tradovate, ​NinjaTrader, ​TradingView, ​DeepCharts
NYS Markets: MT5, ​PROPENGINE, ​Volumetrica, ​DeepCharts, ​ATAS, ​Quantower

For traders in Korea

Sign-up from Korea
Blue Guardian: Available
NYS Markets: No info
Korean support
Blue Guardian: Not supported
NYS Markets: Not supported
Payment methods
Blue Guardian: Card, ​Crypto
NYS Markets: Card, ​Crypto
Nasdaq, Hang Seng, gold
Blue Guardian: Nasdaq not in the instrument listHang Seng not in the instrument listGold tradable
NYS Markets: Nasdaq not in the instrument listHang Seng not in the instrument listGold not in the instrument list

Cashback & deals

Cashback
Blue Guardian: None
NYS Markets: None
Active deals
Blue Guardian: None
NYS Markets: None

Highlights only mark objective figures (lower prices and targets, higher profit splits and loss limits, shorter payout times). Most prop firm funded accounts use simulated capital; each firm page shows its own funded account type.

FAQ

Which is cheaper, Blue Guardian or NYS Markets?

Based on each firm's cheapest plan (first payment including any activation fee): Blue Guardian from $26.66 ($5K account), NYS Markets from $38 ($10K account). The account sizes differ, so per $10K, Blue Guardian is lower (Blue Guardian: $0.50 · NYS Markets: $9.90).

What's the maximum profit split at Blue Guardian and NYS Markets?

Blue Guardian offers up to 90% and NYS Markets up to 80%. Some plans go higher with add-ons. Funded accounts use simulated capital.

Are Blue Guardian and NYS Markets funded accounts real money?

Funded account capital, based on the listed plans — Blue Guardian: Simulated capital; NYS Markets: Simulated capital. At both firms you trade simulated capital, not real funds.

Which trading platforms do Blue Guardian and NYS Markets offer?

Blue Guardian offers MT5, Match-Trader, TradeLocker, Tradovate, NinjaTrader, TradingView, DeepCharts, and NYS Markets offers MT5, PROPENGINE, Volumetrica, DeepCharts, ATAS, Quantower.

How long do payouts take at Blue Guardian and NYS Markets?

As stated by each firm — Blue Guardian: Same day to 1 day, NYS Markets: 1–2 days.

When does the daily loss limit reset at Blue Guardian and NYS Markets?

Blue Guardian resets daily at 10:00 p.m. UTC (US Eastern time 17:00, UTC−5) and NYS Markets at 9:00 p.m. UTC. These follow each firm's own reference time, so the UTC time can shift by an hour with daylight saving time.

Blue Guardian: · Source: blueguardian.com (opens in a new tab)

NYS Markets: · Source: terms.nysmarkets.com (opens in a new tab)

Firms can change their rules, so check the official site again before you pay.